The Repercussions of Kitsch

Story by Farris Wahbeh
Illustration by Sarah Oates

After Schwarzenegger’s victory in the special California recall election, maybe it’s time we reassess democracy. Or is it?

Is it time to reassess democracy when entertainment is an integral part of politics? Is America fundamentally a farce? A comic charade?

Is there a line between politics and political satire?

Much like Reagan, must you have starred in possibly the worst films to be a contender in American politics?

If democracy can only work when it feels like a movie trailer for the next high-budget, straight-to-video comedy, it should make us question what a country that is run “by the people and for the people” really looks like. And while California’s recall election enjoyed a high kitsch factor, the repercussions it may leave in its wake are beginning to unravel.

If Schwarzenegger isn’t a politician, who is going to run his office? The web that weaves through this story is rather tangled, yet makes clear why Schwarzenegger won.

The story begins when Schwarzenegger met with former Enron chieftain Ken Lay. On October 3, 2001, investigative journalist Greg Palast reported that the Foundation for Taxpayers and Consumer Rights (FTCR) discovered internal emails of the Enron Corporation from May 2001. The memos detail meetings that were scheduled as an opportunity to gain business community support for Enron’s “comprehensive solution” to the energy crisis. The crisis in question was California’s manipulated energy shortage of 2001. In fact, the meetings were scheduled ten days after rolling blackouts occurred in California.

The meetings also came as a response to the deregulation of energy companies and how best to handle it. The California energy crisis was one example of how deregulation can affect a state. In one of the emails, Enron’s VP of Public Relations makes it clear that “We’d like to position this meeting as an insider’s conversation of what’s going on with the energy situation. This meeting should be for principals only.”
Related Links:

To view the Enron memos found by FTCR: consumerwatchdog.org

To view Greg Palast’s articles: gregpalast.com

To view Gov. Schwarzenegger’s energy proposals: joinarnold.com


Among the people on the list of attendees at the Enron meeting in Los Angeles’ Peninsula Hotel on May 17, 2001 were Schwarzenegger, Ken Lay (Enron CEO and close friend of George W. Bush), and Mike Milken, a felon convicted of securities fraud violations who was sentenced to prison and forced to pay a fine of $1.1 billion.
Fast-forward to 2002, when Lieutenant Governor Cruz Bustamente filed a lawsuit under the “Unfair Business Practices Act” in a California court against major power companies. The lawsuit was to compel major energy companies, including Enron, Reliant, Dynegy, Williams Company, and other Texas corporations, to repay California customers for fraudulent services. The evidence mounted against them in the form of falsified reporting of sales transactions, megawatt “laundering,” and fake power delivery scheduling.

At the same time, the administration of Governor Gray Davis was demanding George Bush’s energy regulators FERC to order a $9 billion refund.

So what does this all mean? Is it really a conspiracy? Is California’s new governor really a spokesman for major energy companies?

At press time, during his first week in office, Schwarzenegger is advocating the deregulation of the state’s electricity markets. As one of his first moves this push seemed to come as a surprise, given that Schwarzenegger made hardly any mention of deregulation during his campaign. Furthermore, three days after the new governor was elected, a Schwarzenegger aide announced that the governor-elect intends to settle the pending energy fraud lawsuits. How the lawsuits are going to be settled, however, has not yet been mentioned.

So what was Schwarzenegger’s response when questioned about this meeting between himself, Lay, and Milken? The Governor-elect says he doesn’t remember the details of the meeting. And, according to Palast, when Schwarzenegger was asked directly by a woman in Bakersfield, “Are you in bed with Ken Lay?,” the Governor responded, “I certainly wasn’t in bed with you.”

Back to Regulars